CousinChart — family connections made simple
Advertisement

How to Find Out If You Are a Mayflower Descendant

How to Find Out If You Are a Mayflower Descendant

Here is how to find out if you are a Mayflower descendant: build your family tree backward one generation at a time, with a record for every link, until you reach colonial New England, then see whether your line connects to one of the passenger families with known descendants. A family story is a starting point, but only documented links from you back to a passenger prove it.

Every November, as Thanksgiving gets close, many families wonder whether the "we came over on the Mayflower" story is true. Sometimes it is. Many Americans with deep New England roots really do descend from the 1620 passengers. Sometimes the story turns out to be a mix-up with a later ship, or a relative by marriage. The steps below help you find out which, using mostly free records.

⛵ Where are you in your Mayflower search? Tap one:
Pick one 👇
Name any relative with the free relationship calculator →

Step 1: Start With What You Already Know

Write down yourself, your parents, your four grandparents and your eight great-grandparents, with full names, dates and places. A pedigree chart is the perfect format for this because it shows only your direct ancestors and nothing else.

Then mark which branches have New England roots. Mayflower lines almost always pass through Massachusetts, and often through Connecticut, Rhode Island, Maine, Vermont or New Hampshire, before spreading west and south with later generations. A branch that arrived from Germany in 1880 can't be a Mayflower line. A branch that was in Ohio by 1820 with parents born in Massachusetts is worth following.

Next, collect your family's own clues:

A relative's old lineage-society certificate is the best clue you can find. If an aunt or great-grandparent was already accepted, much of the work may be done, and you may only need to prove your link to that person.

Step 2: Learn the Passenger Families

About 100 passengers sailed on the Mayflower in 1620. Roughly half died during the first hard winter, and not everyone who survived left children with descendants living today. That's why your goal is to connect to one of the passengers whose lines are documented.

These are some of the best-known Mayflower surnames whose lines continue today:

Surname Notes
Alden John Alden and Priscilla Mullins, one of the most famous couples
Allerton Isaac Allerton and family
Bradford William Bradford, longtime governor of Plymouth Colony
Brewster William Brewster, church elder
Billington John Billington and family
Chilton James Chilton and daughter Mary
Cooke Francis Cooke and son John
Doty Edward Doty
Eaton Francis Eaton and family
Fuller Samuel Fuller and Edward Fuller
Hopkins Stephen Hopkins and family
Howland John Howland, who famously fell overboard and was rescued
Mullins William Mullins, through daughter Priscilla
Rogers Thomas Rogers and son Joseph
Soule George Soule
Standish Myles Standish
Tilley John Tilley and daughter Elizabeth
Warren Richard Warren
White William White and son Peregrine, born aboard ship
Winslow Edward Winslow and others

This is not a complete list, and sharing a surname proves nothing on its own. Many Mayflower lines pass through daughters, so the passenger's surname may disappear from your tree after one or two generations. A great-great-grandmother named Ruth Bassett can be a perfectly good Mayflower line even though no one in your family has carried a passenger name for 300 years.

Advertisement

Step 3: Work Backward, One Generation at a Time

This is the heart of how to find out if you are a Mayflower descendant. Don't jump straight to the 1600s and try to find "your" Pilgrim. Instead, prove each generation before moving back to the next one.

For each ancestor, try to find records that show:

  1. When and where they were born
  2. Who their parents were
  3. Who they married
  4. When and where they died

The parent-child link is the part that matters most. A birth record that names both parents is strong. A death certificate naming parents, a will that names children, or a church baptism record also link one generation to the next.

Records that work well for each period

Time period Best records
1900s to today Birth and death certificates, marriage licenses, obituaries, Social Security records
1850 to 1900 Census records listing every household member, vital records, family Bibles, county histories
1790 to 1850 Probate and wills, land deeds, church records, town vital records, early censuses (head of household only before 1850)
1620 to 1790 Town vital records, church records, probate, land records, colonial court records

A free FamilySearch guide is a good companion here. Many New England town records, church registers and probate files have been digitized and can be searched or browsed for free.

Step 4: Match Your Line to the Published Passenger Families

Once your tree reaches the 1700s in New England, start comparing it with published genealogies of the passenger families. The General Society of Mayflower Descendants has spent many decades publishing carefully researched multi-generation studies of each passenger's family, often called the "Silver Books" because of their covers. These trace descendants through the first five or more generations.

If an ancestor you've proven appears in one of these studies, with the same spouse, children and places, you've likely found your connection. Libraries with genealogy collections often hold them, and you can ask your local library about access.

Watch for these pitfalls:

If you've found that you connect to several colonial families and want a sense of how many ancestors you have at each level, our guide on how many ancestors you have shows how quickly the numbers grow. It also explains why so many people with New England roots end up with at least one Pilgrim.

Step 5: Gather Proof for Every Link

If you want to join a lineage society or simply want a line you can trust, you'll need proof for every generation from you back to the passenger. Most of the work is in the last few generations (you, your parents, grandparents and great-grandparents), because those are the generations no published book covers.

For each generation, collect:

When no single record does the job, several smaller records together can prove a link. For example, a census showing a child in the household, a will naming that child, and a deed in which the child sells inherited land.

Label and cite everything clearly. Our guide on how to cite genealogy sources shows a simple format that lineage-society reviewers and future relatives can follow.

Step 6: Decide Whether to Apply to a Lineage Society

You don't have to join anything to know you're a Mayflower descendant. But joining a lineage society gives your line an independent review, and it saves future relatives from doing the same work again.

The General Society of Mayflower Descendants has state societies throughout the country. Each state society has volunteers who help applicants. The usual process is:

  1. Contact your state society and tell them which passenger you believe you descend from.
  2. Ask whether anyone in your line has already been accepted. A relative's approved application can shorten your work a great deal.
  3. Complete the application with your documents.
  4. Work with the society's reviewers if they ask for more proof.

If you also have ancestors who served in the American Revolution, the same records often help with that application too. Our guide on how to join the DAR covers that separate lineage process.

Advertisement

Mistakes to Avoid

Starting with the passenger and working down. You'll end up chasing thousands of descendants. Start with yourself and work up.

Assuming a surname proves the line. Plenty of people named Alden or Brewster have no Mayflower connection, and plenty of people with neither name do.

Confusing ships. Many family stories mix up the Mayflower with later ships that brought settlers to New England during the 1600s. Those are interesting ancestors too, just not Mayflower passengers.

Skipping recent generations. People often have great records for 1700 and none for 1940. Every generation needs proof.

Trusting one online tree. Treat any tree without sources as a lead, not an answer.

How to Find Out If You Are a Mayflower Descendant: A Quick Checklist

An Example of How a Line Comes Together

Here's a simplified, made-up example that shows how the steps fit together in practice.

Say your grandmother was born in Michigan in 1915. Her birth certificate names her parents, who were born in New York. The 1880 census shows her grandfather as a boy in a New York household with parents born in Vermont. A county history and a will take that Vermont family back to Massachusetts in the 1700s. Town vital records there show a marriage between your ancestor and a woman whose maiden name is Soule. Finally, you find that woman, along with her husband and children, in the published study of George Soule's descendants.

Notice what happened along the way:

That's how to find out if you are a Mayflower descendant in real life: not one dramatic discovery, but a chain of ordinary records, each one linking a parent to a child. Keep a research log as you go, so you always know which links are proven and which still need work.

FAQ

How do I know if my family came over on the Mayflower?

Build your tree backward one generation at a time, with records for each link, until you reach colonial New England. Then compare your ancestors with the published genealogies of the passenger families. A family story is a clue, not proof.

Can a DNA test prove I'm a Mayflower descendant?

No. DNA can show you're related to other people, but the passengers lived about 400 years ago, too far back for DNA alone to prove a specific link. Lineage societies rely on documents for each generation.

What are the most common Mayflower surnames?

Some well-known passenger surnames with living descendants include Alden, Bradford, Brewster, Cooke, Fuller, Hopkins, Howland, Soule, Standish, Warren and White. Many lines pass through daughters, so you may descend from a passenger without carrying the surname.

Do I need to join a society to be a Mayflower descendant?

No. You are a descendant whether or not you join. Joining gives your research an independent review and creates a record that future relatives can build on.

What if my line has a gap I can't prove?

Look for indirect evidence: wills, land deeds, church records and census households can together prove a parent-child link. State lineage-society volunteers can often suggest records you haven't tried.

Where should I start if I know nothing about my family history?

Start with yourself and your parents, then talk to older relatives and gather family papers. Fill in a pedigree chart as far back as you can before you look for records.

How long does it take to trace a Mayflower line?

It depends on how much your family already knows and how well each generation was recorded. Some people connect to a published line in a few weekends; others need months to prove one difficult link. Working steadily, one generation at a time, is the surest approach, and a relative's earlier lineage application can save a great deal of time.

Advertisement