"Brothers and Sisters Have I None" Riddle: The Answer, Step by Step (Plus 10 More)
The answer to the riddle "Brothers and sisters have I none, but this man's father is my father's son" is my son. Since the speaker has no brothers, "my father's son" must be the speaker himself, so the riddle really says "this man's father is me," which makes the man in the picture the speaker's son. Below is the full riddle, a step-by-step walk-through, why so many people answer "myself," the classic twist with the words switched, and 10 more clean family riddles for the holiday table.
Tap to reveal each step of the answer.
▶ Solve real family puzzles in the free relationship calculator
The riddle
A man is looking at a portrait. Someone asks him, "Whose picture are you looking at?" He answers:
"Brothers and sisters have I none, but this man's father is my father's son."
Who is in the picture?
Step-by-step answer
- "Brothers and sisters have I none." The speaker is an only child.
- "My father's son." The speaker's father has only one son, because the speaker has no brothers. So "my father's son" is the speaker himself.
- Swap it in: "This man's father is me."
- So the man in the picture is the speaker's son.
Why so many people say "myself"
The phrase "my father's son" sounds like the answer, so people stop there and say "the speaker." But that phrase describes the father of the man in the picture, not the man himself. Draw it as a little family tree and it clicks:
| Generation | Who |
|---|---|
| Top | The speaker's father |
| Middle | The speaker ("my father's son") |
| Bottom | The man in the picture (the speaker's son) |
The twist: "this man's son is my father's son"
A well-known variation switches one word: "Brothers and sisters have I none, but this man's son is my father's son." Now "my father's son" (the speaker) is the son of the man in the picture, so the picture shows the speaker's father.
| Version | The man in the picture is... |
|---|---|
| "This man's father is my father's son" | The speaker's son |
| "This man's son is my father's son" | The speaker's father |
Try both on your family. Most people get one right and one wrong.
10 more family relationship riddles
All clean, all fair, and all good for a holiday table or a car ride. Answers are under each one.
- Two fathers and two sons go fishing. Each catches one fish, but they bring home only three fish. How?
Answer: There are only three people: a grandfather, his son and his grandson. The middle one is both a father and a son. - A boy has as many brothers as sisters, but each of his sisters has only half as many sisters as brothers. How many boys and girls are in the family?
Answer: Four boys and three girls. Each boy has 3 brothers and 3 sisters; each girl has 2 sisters and 4 brothers. - Who is your mother's brother's only sister?
Answer: Your mother. - Your aunt's brother isn't your uncle. Who is he?
Answer: Your father. (Your aunt is his sister.) - If your uncle's sister isn't your aunt, who is she?
Answer: Your mother. - Sarah's mother has four children: North, South, East and...?
Answer: Sarah! (Not West.) - Two kids were born to the same mother on the same day of the same year, but they aren't twins. How?
Answer: They're two of a set of triplets (or more). - A grandmother, two mothers and two daughters go to a movie. Each buys one ticket, but only three tickets are bought. How?
Answer: There are three people: a grandmother, her daughter and her granddaughter. - What has many branches but no leaves, no trunk and no fruit?
Answer: A family tree. (A bank works too!) - A girl says, "I have a brother, and he has no brothers." How can that be?
Answer: He's the only boy in the family, so he has sisters but no brothers.
How to use family riddles at a holiday gathering
- Riddle cards at each place: write one riddle per card and read them out over dessert.
- Kids vs grown-ups: kids read the riddles, grown-ups try to answer. Then switch.
- Draw it out: keep paper and pencils on the table, so people can sketch the family tree for the tricky ones.
- Make your own: use real family names. "Who is Aunt Rosa's brother's only daughter?" (Your cousin, if it's Uncle Mike's.)
- Prize: the first to solve the main riddle picks the next game.
For more holiday family fun, see our Thanksgiving relationship cheat sheet, the Christmas table who's-who placemat and family relationship idioms. Kids can learn the basics with how to explain cousins to kids.
Common mistakes
- Answering "myself" to the classic version. It's "my son."
- Mixing up the two versions. "Father" in the riddle points down to a son; "son" points up to a father.
- Forgetting "only child." The first line is the key: without it, "my father's son" could be a brother.
Want to solve real family puzzles? The free relationship calculator sorts out any two relatives in a few taps.
▶ Solve real family puzzles in the free relationship calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the answer to "Brothers and sisters have I none, but this man's father is my father's son"?
The man in the picture is the speaker's son. The speaker has no brothers, so "my father's son" is the speaker, which makes him the man's father.
Why isn't the answer "myself"?
"My father's son" describes the father of the man in the picture, not the man himself. That father is the speaker, so the man is the speaker's son.
What if the riddle says "this man's son is my father's son"?
Then the man in the picture is the speaker's father, because the speaker is the man's son.
What are some easy family relationship riddles?
"Two fathers and two sons go fishing but bring home three fish" (grandfather, father and son), and "Sarah's mother has four children: North, South, East and...?" (Sarah).
Is the riddle about a man or a woman?
The classic version has a man speaking, but the logic works the same if the speaker is a woman with no brothers: the man in the picture is her son.




